“excellent and clearly written…in the vanguard of the area”
“timely, insightful and brave…a lesson for all”
“a penetrating analysis…written with energy and style. One that I think will earn an enduring place on the Brexit bookshelf”
“accessible and absorbing…a must-read”
As an academic, I have written works and given lectures on the psychological aspects of many social issues, including fascism and racism. Over the years, I have worked with several advocacy groups, most recently with Galway Anti Racism Network.
I regularly receive online harassment from different types of trolls, and often from Far-Right activists. Last night, I received an email suggesting that I am about to be attacked by a targetted campaign of harassment.
On Tuesday last, 26 November, I gave a short presentation at a Public Meeting in Galway organised by Galway Anti Racism Network, which was live-streamed. In explaining the importance of respecting racial identities, I stated that “there is nothing wrong with being a proud white person.”
The people who emailed me have now created a lame 11-second YouTube video emphasising this sentence, arguing that it must mean that I am a white supremacist.
* * *
These people are claiming to be anti-racists, offended by my white supremacy. But they are no anti-racists. They are the full-blown Far Right, they are aping the language of anti-racism, and they are doing it very badly.
I am aware that, in recent months, other local anti-racism activists and politicians have been targetted by very similar campaigns of emailing, YouTube posts, and bogus petitions. In this sense, there is a wider context.
They have also posted a petition on the Change.org website, entitled “Remove Brian Hughes as Professor at NUIGalway.” Notably, the first person to sign the petition calls me a “good for nothing SCUM bag.” I think I’ve heard his name before.
Take a look at the narrative in their email:
Professor Hughes, re: this video of you: [YOUTUBE LINK]
You advocate violent boycott and race-paranoia in Galway on the basis of Irish history. You then betray Irish identity with your white pride allowances, which has little to do with anti-colonial Irishness. Your lecture could have protected debate, instead you sought diagnosis and expulsion of sinners against the one dogma. We need someone to fairly hear Irish ethnic advocacy in Ireland, than the usual colonial apologia couched in anti-racism. If you would organize a conference to counter-balance the Harbour Hotel event, we could correct the issues highlighted by your thoughts on white pride. We are not promoting the video or petition as yet, and hope to hear from you soon about organizing an event to contextualize excerpt thoughts you or we or any of us might have. [CHANGE.ORG LINK] [YOUTUBE LINK AGAIN]
We can chat at antiracismgalway@[EMAIL]
They somehow manage to claim that I “advocate violent boycott and race-paranoia,” (which is fabricated and truly bizarre) before “betraying” Irish identity with my “white pride.” They go on to refer to “diagnosis,” “dogma,” “apologia,” and all the “anti-colonial” aspects of my discourse.
They are imitating the language of academic anti-racism in order to imply that they are the true anti-racists, and that I am the one promoting racism. In fact, they are adopting the persona of a full-blown anti racism organisation, “ARGH”, in order to pull this off.
They end with an implied threat — they want me to organise a “counter-balance” event, or else they are going to go public on me.
Good luck with that.
* * *
I’m no lawyer, but I can see a lot going on here that would interest a lawyer. Or even the police.
The links to the YouTube video and Change.org petition are incorporated in the email that was sent to me. In these situations, it is normally advised not to click on such links, as this serves to boost the traffic to the websites concerned, improves their digital footprint, and boosts their visibility to search engines. Therefore, I have posted a screengrab of the petition page above, and below is a link to a video file containing the YouTube post.
While I have your attention, here is a link to my post on Alt-Right/Far-Right manoeuvres in Oughterard. Strangely enough, this post received a spike of a hundred or so referrals from Facebook the night before last.
You know what they say. I must be doing something right.
Social controversies are frequently seized upon by bigots. In Britain, for example, the immediate aftermath of the Brexit referendum saw a sharp increase in racist incidents, with reports of people being harassed on the street, jeered at in shops, and barracked at passport control in airports. There is even a name for this unleashing of gleeful bigotry. Paul Bagguley, a sociologist at Leeds University, calls it “celebratory racism.”
You see, racists do celebrate. They do so whenever they have some kind of ‘victory’, an occasion that allows them to revel in the sheer discomfort of mainstream society.
Psychologists will tell you that celebrations fulfil important social functions. They solidify social bonds, bolster the identity of the in-group, and communicate group-level encouragement to your fellows, especially during times of stress. In other words, celebration is itself a tool of social manipulation.
You celebrate in order to collaborate.
Celebratory racism, then, is team-building for bigots. A spontaneous outpouring of hysteria designed to advance the racist cause.
* * *
This week’s news from Oughterard — where protesters succeeded in blocking an accommodation centre for asylum seekers from being opened in their village — was greeted with people cheering at the village’s picket line. One reporter explicitly described the atmosphere as one of “celebration”.
The organisers of the Oughterard protests have repeatedly told journalists that they are not racists. Instead, their objections to the Direct Provision centre are described as relating to the “inhumane conditions for asylum seekers” that such a centre would offer.
But online, few people celebrating the outcome seemed concerned about the inhumanity of Ireland’s Direct Provision system. By and large, reactions were more along the following lines:
I actually gathered several similar examples, but in the spirit of not-feeding-the-trolls, I have decided against publishing them here.
But I will point out that they often included full-blown Nazi:
@RTÉNews: Plans to turn a former hotel in Co Galway into a Direct Provision centre have been abandoned, following protests by people in Oughterard | bit.ly/2oTWqh7
@[REDACTED NAME]: 1488
Readers not up to speed on neofascist semiotics might be wondering what “1488” even means. Here is an explanation from the Anti-Defamation League:
1488 is a combination of two popular white supremacist numeric symbols. The first symbol is 14, which is shorthand for the “14 Words” slogan: “We must secure the existence of our people and a future for white children.” The second is 88, which stands for “Heil Hitler” (H being the 8th letter of the alphabet). Together, the numbers form a general endorsement of white supremacy and its beliefs.
As such, they are ubiquitous within the white supremacist movement – as graffiti, in graphics and tattoos, even in screen names and e-mail addresses, such as firstname.lastname@example.org. Some white supremacists will even price racist merchandise, such as t-shirts or compact discs, for $14.88.
In other words, “1488” is international code for:
“Protect white people!”
Fascists online often speak in code. They do it partly to disguise their views, partly to communicate with like-minded bigots on Twitter, but most of all they do it for fun. A bit of neofascist craic.
It’s the psychology of tribalism. The shared language, the codes and the symbols, even the high-vis vests, are all part of the social identity that ties these racists together.
* * *
Ordinary mainstream Irish people — including many good citizens of Oughterard who were so dismissive of anyone who criticised their protest — really do need to wise up.
And participating in your celebrations.
Not only were the Oughterard protesters “jubilant” and in “high spirits” after news broke that the Direct Provision centre had been abandoned, they even organised a party to celebrate their ‘victory’ — at one point live-streaming it on their notorious Facebook page:
Michael Clifford in the Irish Examiner was appropriately judgmental:
The whooping and hollering was in bad taste. Last Tuesday, protestors outside the former Connemara Gateway Hotel near the village of Oughterard were letting it rip. They were thrilled that their two-week protest had succeeded.
The owner of the premises had bowed to pressure and withdrawn his tender to house a direct provision centre there.
The protesters claimed their glee was directed at the Department of Justice, the Government, the system. But the reality is that the spontaneous joy also sent a message to some of the most vulnerable people on the planet. Any asylum seeker aware of the scenario would be compelled to conclude that they were not welcome in Oughterard.
The on-the-ground protest organisers remain adamant that nothing could have been further from their minds.
* * *
The Oughterard protesters see themselves in a positive light. But their protests have undoubtedly energised a burgeoning fascist fringe in wider Irish society.
The overlap with Oughterard was obvious to anyone who follows these events on social media. The trolls gloating about Oughterard were, by and large, the very same trolls who were attacking this family with online abuse and sneers.
As with Brexit, the mainstreaming of anti-immigrant discourse has consequences beyond the immediate moment. It lowers the social bar. It threatens to liberate a freshly enthused wave of public bigotry.
For a certain type of person, celebratory racism is addictive. When it comes to getting high on gleeful bigotry, these folks are complete junkies. It’s only a matter of time before they are looking for another fix.
So when exactly is Ireland going to get serious about racism?
It will need to be soon.
In the meantime, however, be prepared for more Oughterards.