Want to lose weight? Hint: Do NOT eat chocolate cake

Mmmmm. Chocolate cake. As in “cake” with “chocolate” in it. It’s a straightforward, yet somehow radical, concept. Except it’s not that radical. It’s just everyday, common-or-garden, run-of-the-mill chocolate cake. Tastes nice, but is not good for you; eating lots of it makes you fat, etc., etc., etc. Everybody knows this. I mean, if you were to stop eating, say, fruit for breakfast every morning, and started to eat chocolate cake for breakfast instead, that would just be crazy, wouldn’t it? For one thing, it would make you put on weight, that would. Wouldn’t it?

But have a look at these headlines: “Want to lose weight? Eat chocolate cake for breakfast, say researchers” (Daily Mirror), “Chocolate cake breakfast could help you lose weight” (Daily Telegraph), “Happy Chocolate Day! Chocolate cake for breakfast could help you lose weight” (Huffington Post), “Dessert with breakfast can help weight loss” (MSN New Zealand), “Desserts at Breakfast Could Lead to Weight Loss (Really!)” (Allure Magazine), and many more.

It’s those darned “researchers” again, turning the breakfast tables on us and grabbing the media’s attention. According to these guys, it seems as though eating chocolate cake at breakfast actually helps you to lose weight, rather than put it on. Whodathunkit? I guess that’s why people who eat lots of cake are just so thin.

And that’s that, I suppose. End of. Nothing to see here.

But hang on a minute…

…SERIOUSLY!? Eating cake for breakfast HELPS YOU LOSE WEIGHT? Are you MAD? Well, no not mad. Just mistaken. You see, while the various headlines circulating on this story are kind of right, they are actually only half-right. Which makes them half-wrong. So, in other words, they’re wrong.

Let’s do some parsing. The basic shape of these headlines is something like “X could help Y“, with X signifying chocolate cake for breakfast and Y signifying weight-loss. So “X could help Y” becomes “Chocolate cake for breakfast could help you lose weight“.

If you want to use technical language, we would say that Chocolate cake for breakfast (i.e., X) is the independent variable, while weight-loss (i.e., Y) is the dependent variable. The first is called “independent” because you can choose to do it or not to do it; the second is called “dependent” because it depends on the first.

In the papers

However, the original research was a little more subtle than that. First of all, the researchers were looking at a specific group of people, who were (a) already overweight and (b) in the habit of eating cake anyway. In other words, they were not looking at average-weight people who simply might be thinking about adopting a cake-for-breakfast lifestyle. Secondly, the researchers were not testing whether chocolate cake affected weight, but instead were looking at the impact of the time-of-day at which people ate their cake.

Following a controlled study, the researchers found that their sample of already-overweight habitual cake-consumers were more likely to lose weight if they moved their carbohydrate consumption to the mornings. (This was most likely because their metabolisms were more active at that time, meaning that they burned off more calories than they would have in the evenings. In addition, they had the rest of the day to move about a bit and burn off some more, rather than simply going to bed shortly after eating, thereby allowing all that fat stuff to be absorbed into their bodies unimpeded.)

So to revert to technical language, you could say that the headline writers were failing to realise that the independent variable chocolate cake consumption — was being specifically qualified by a moderating variabletime of day. In reality, it was two variables rather than one.

In reality

In other words, the correct format for the headlines should have been “X for Y could help Z“, with X signifying chocolate cake, Y signifying breakfast, and Z signifying weight-loss. And the headlines should only apply to people who eat cake on a daily basis anyway.

So headlines like “Chocolate cake for breakfast could help you lose weight” are missing some critical information. First of all “you” doesn’t mean “you” unless “you” are an overweight person who eats cake on a daily basis. And secondly, it should be clarified that the key variable here is “breakfast” and not “chocolate cake”. So the proper headline should be something like this:

Chocolate cake for breakfast — in contrast to chocolate cake at other times of the day — could help you lose the weight you put on in the first place by eating cake in the afternoons and evenings

Now I admit that isn’t particularly catchy. That’s often the problem with accuracy. However, something like this would have been both catchy and accurate:

Want to lose weight? Then LAY OFF THE CAKE!

But that wouldn’t have been news. And that’s something of a dilemma if you’re a newspaper (or a person who wants to eat cake every day and would like an evidence-base for doing so).

I guess we just can’t have our cake and eat it…

* * *

Related on The Science Bit
What women want…to be exploited by capitalists
Stop the spread of the ecological fallacy
A study not worth its salt? 



Categories: Allure Magazine, Daily Mirror, Daily Telegraph, Dieting, Food, Health, Huffington Post, MSN NZ, Naive optimism, Newspapers & Magazines, Research design

5 replies

  1. G’Day! Thesciencebit,
    Maybe a little off topic, however, Eating dried rice cakes and wilted lettuce is no way to spend their lunch hours. You do not have to eat only soft foods and boring to cut up. You can eat great and lose weight all at the same time. If you choose quality foods and are willing to try new things, you can get delicious food and lose weight too.
    I look forward to your next post

  2. LOL Your analysis on how headlines overhype their stories just shows how they are willing to lie just to tickle the ears of their readers and keep their audience at bay. Sad but true.

  3. Im an overweight person who eats a fair bit of cake. I shall attempt to replicate this studies results. In the name of Science and all that…

  4. When some one searches for his required thing, therefore he/she desires to be available that in detail,
    thus that thing is maintained over here.

  5. Pounds loss is really a huge industry and there are thousands of weight reduction products and pills. Appetite suppressants help decrease your appetite and food intake resulting in weight reduction.
    Richard Gatling http://www.erectiledysfunctioninmen.com/

»So what do you make of this?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,146 other followers

%d bloggers like this: